Is University Worth It?
What if someone skipped university and went straight to work — in the same industry, on minimum wage? We ran the numbers on a Monash pharmacy degree versus a pharmacy assistant starting at 18. The results might change how you think about the "safe" option.
Wages: All wages are based on the Pharmacy Industry Award MA000012, effective 1 July 2025. Pharmacy assistant progression: Level 1 (year 1) → Level 2 (year 2) → Level 3 (year 3 onwards, capped). Pharmacist progression: Pharmacist (year 6) → Experienced Pharmacist (year 7 onwards, capped). No management or leadership roles are assumed for either path.
Tax: Australian 2025-26 individual income tax rates applied, including the 2% Medicare levy. Tax-free threshold: $18,200. Marginal rates: 16% ($18,201–$45,000), 30% ($45,001–$135,000), 37% ($135,001–$190,000), 45% ($190,001+).
HECS-HELP: Student contribution based on Monash University P6001 fee calculator for 2026 — $9,537 per year (Band 2 CSP). HECS debt is indexed annually at 3.2% (capped at lower of CPI or WPI). Repayments calculated using the 2025-26 marginal repayment system with a $67,000 minimum threshold.
Superannuation: Employer contributions at the current rate of 12% of gross salary, applied to all employment income. Super balances grow at the same assumed investment return rate.
Investment returns: Default 7% annual return, broadly consistent with long-term Australian equity index and superannuation fund performance. Adjustable via the slider above.
Living costs: Both individuals are assumed to live at home for the first 5 years (until the pharmacy student graduates), then independently. The pharmacy student's living costs during study are treated as debt (reducing net wealth), consistent with full-time study and no part-time income. Neither individual earns overtime or additional income — if either did, the same opportunity would be available to both.
Net wealth: Calculated as personal investment portfolio + superannuation balance − outstanding HECS debt. All figures are nominal (not inflation-adjusted). Wage growth is not modelled beyond award rate progression, as both paths are capped at non-management levels.
- The Australia Institute — "People are starting with much larger HECS/HELP debts than in the past" (May 2024)
- Australian Government — "Australia's biggest-ever student debt cut has begun, wiping $16 billion" (Nov 2025)
- Victoria University Mitchell Institute — "The changing value of a university degree" (Nov 2025)
- Times Higher Education — "Graduate salary premium declining at all levels in Australia" (Aug 2025)
- Centre for Independent Studies — "Degree Inflation: Undermining the value of higher education" (Feb 2024)
- QILT — Graduate Outcomes Survey 2024 (2024)
- Indeed Hiring Lab — "Australia's Graduate Hiring Slows" (May 2025)
- NestPath — "HECS Debt and Home Loans Australia 2026" (Feb 2026)
- Monash University — Bachelor of Pharmacy (Honours) and Master of Pharmacy (P6001) (2026)
- Monash University — Course Fee Calculator (Domestic CSP) (2026)
- Fair Work Ombudsman — Pharmacy Industry Award MA000012 Pay Guide (Effective 1 July 2025)
- Australian Taxation Office — Study and training loan repayment thresholds and rates 2025-26 (2025-26)
- Study Assist — Student contribution amounts (2026)
- The Aussie Corporate — "University Degree Value Under Fresh Scrutiny" (Nov 2025)